Case Examples

For over a decade, Melanie has successfully argued criminal cases and represented clients before a range of tribunals and commissions. Below are some examples of results she's achieved for other clients:

 

+ Homicide and kidnapping

Murder Appeal
(R. v. R.H.)

Appeal against conviction and sentence for murder. Appeal allowed: new trial ordered. Bail pending new trial granted, while opposed by the Crown.

Accessory to Murder Charge
(R. v. M.T)

Accused’s charge of accessory after the fact to murder withdrawn.

Kidnapping Charges
(R. v. J.G.)

Accused acquitted of kidnapping and forcible confinement.

Kidnapping Charges
(R. v. S.P.)

Accused was charged with kidnapping, forcible confinement, attempt robbery, and breach of probation, in a case involving the alleged use of a firearm. Following a contested bail hearing, Melanie successfully obtained release of the client on his own recognizance. Accused found guilty of only one count of simple assault — all other charges withdrawn.

+ Sexual Assault

Sexual Assault Charge
(R. v. M. R.)

Accused acquitted of all counts of sexual assault and simple assault involving multiple complainants.

Sexual Assault Charge
(R. v. M. V.)

Appeal against conviction for sexual assault allowed.

Sexual Assault Charge
(R. v. H. L.)

Accused acquitted of sexual assault.

Voyeurism and Related Charges
(R. v. J. J.)

Several counts of voyeurism, mischief, and unlawful use of computer withdrawn.

Sexual Assault Charge
(R. v. V.O.)

Accused acquitted of sexual assault and criminal harassment after complainant’s evidence found to be unreliable.

+ Gun Possession

Possession of Firearm Charges
(R. v. R.B.)

Accused’s multiple charges of unauthorized possession of firearm, theft, possession of break-in instruments, and possession of property obtained by crime withdrawn after demonstration of serious Charter issues.

Possession of Firearm Charges
(R. v. K.R.)

Accused’s multiple firearms-related charges withdrawn.

Possession of Firearm Charges
(R. v. A.L.)

Accused’s multiple firearms-related charges withdrawn.

+ Drug Offences

Drug Possession and Related Charges
(R. v. X.Y.)

Accused’s multiple drug and proceeds of crime charges, and other related offences, withdrawn mid-trial.

Drug Possession Charges
(R. v. K.D.)

Accused’s charge of possession of cocaine withdrawn after demonstration of serious Charter issues.

Drug Trafficking Charges
(R. v. K.P.)

Accused’s charge of trafficking heroin withdrawn.

Drug Possession and Related Charges
(R. v. R.F.)

Accused’s multiple drug and property-related offences stayed.

Marijuana Production Charges
(R. v. G.M.)

Accused’s charges of production of marijuana (grow-op) and mischief over $5000 withdrawn.

Drug Possession Charges
(R. v. A.D.)

All charges of drug possession, proceeds of crime, pointing a firearm, assault, forcible confinement, and utter threat withdrawn, after serious issues raised regarding the legality of the police search and the reliability of the complainant’s claims. Seized funds returned to client.

+ Obstruction of Justice

Obstruction of Justice and Related Charges
(R. v. C.C.)

Accused’s charges of obstruction of justice, intimidation of a justice system participant X 3, and utter threat withdrawn after preliminary hearing.

+ Robbery and Theft

Theft and Related Charges
(R. v. N.C.)

Accused’s charges of theft over, assault resist arrest, and other charges withdrawn.

Robbery and Drug Possession Charges
(R. v. V.K.)

Accused’s multiple charges of robbery X 2, possession of marijuana for the purpose of trafficking, obstruct peace officer and failure to comply X 3 withdrawn.

Break & enter
(R. v. R.M.)

Appeal against conviction and sentence for several break & enter offences. Appeal allowed: new trial ordered.

+ Fraud

Fraud Charges
(R. v. B.C.)

All of the accused’s charges in a moderately large fraud case withdrawn.

+ Assault

Assault Charges
(R. v. M.S.)

Accused acquitted of multiple charges of assault with weapon, assault, weapons dangerous, utter threat.

Assault Charge
(R. v. R.S.)

Accused’s charges of assault with weapon and breach of peace bond withdrawn.

Aggravated Assault and Criminal Negligence Charges
(R. v. M.S.)

Accused acquitted of aggravated assault, criminal negligence cause bodily harm.

Assault Charge
(R. v. A.D.)

All charges of drug possession, proceeds of crime, pointing a firearm, assault, forcible confinement, and utter threat withdrawn, after serious issues raised regarding the legality of the police search and the reliability of the complainant’s claims. Seized funds returned to client.

+ Driving Offences

Impaired Driving Charge
(R. v. I.K.)

Accused’s charge of impaired driving withdrawn following demonstration of serious Charter issues.

Stunt Driving Conviction
(R. v. E.B.)

Accused’s conviction for stunt driving overturned on appeal; charge withdrawn.

Stunt Driving Charges
(R. v. S.S.)

Accused’s charge of stunt driving withdrawn.

+ Sentencing

Drug Trafficking Sentence
(R. v. M.R.)

Crown asked for a penitentiary sentence for an accused convicted of trafficking heroin. Following submissions, accused given a suspended sentence (no prison time).

Drug Trafficking Sentence
(R. v. J.F.)

Accused’s charge of trafficking cocaine was withdrawn after a plea to simple possession. Accused served no jail-time.

+ Bail Hearings

Ms. Webb has conducted countless bail hearings. She has been successful in securing release for offences ranging from guns to kidnapping to murder. She is also well-experienced in preparing and arguing applications for bail pending appeal and has succeeded in obtaining bail for an applicant seeking leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.